Online Advertising | Buy Anything On eBay | Web Directory | Grand Junction Real Estate | Mobile Phone
Saturday night in the Missouri Valley Conference [Archive] - ValleyTalk Forums

PDA

View Full Version : Saturday night in the Missouri Valley Conference


Bigcityp
02-06-2007, 09:02 AM
Just something from the local paper about Saturday Nights in the MVC...

By Steve Ford

Meet the sad sacks of Saturday night
Posted February 5, 2007

--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Welcome to another bizarre Saturday night in the Missouri Valley Conference.

It doesn't really matter who's playing, though, because one thing's for certain on a Saturday night in the Valley: the game will be ugly because the officials are going to stink.

Saturday's home game for the University of Evansville, what would eventually become a 79-71 loss to Northern Iowa, was just another prime example of what has become a running joke in the MVC.

It's all about Saturday night officiating crews. Since all the good referees worked earlier in the day in marquee games, the guys who work Saturday nights are leftovers.

We're talking bad leftovers here, something like serving the surviving snacks from your New Years party for the Super Bowl. They tend to be stale, crumbly and not so good.

Actually, that's being kind. Saturday's crew at Roberts Stadium was awful, not worthy of a junior varsity game at the high school level. In fact, that's exactly what they reminded me of, only these guys should know better.

Let's get their names straight. The lead official, the guy with the shaved head, was Mark Mayhood. The other two, whom I can't differentiate, were Dan Nowakowski and John Moore. We'll consider them an entry.

It didn't really matter, because it was Mayhood who set the tone from the opening tap, which he attempted to throw. It never got higher than Bradley Strickland's elbow and should've been redone. But noooooooo!

And then things went downhill from there. Mayhood started out by dominating the calls. My estimate late in the first half was that he blew 70 percent of the whistles. Other estimates in the press box were higher.

Then, what usually happens in this situation, did. The entry decided it need to start getting involved at a similar level. The result was chaos.

UE coach Steve Merfeld, who's not supposed to comment, did on his coach's show Sunday night. He said, in so many words, it was the worst game he'd seen in his 21 years of coaching.

If it wasn't at the top of my list, it was close. It was terribly inconsistent from all involved. There was a one-step travel called on one trip and running in place with the ball ignored on the next.

Officials within an arm's length of an assault ignored it one trip then called a hard breath on someone's back a foul from across the floor on the next.

All told the numbers were numbing, same as the flow of the game. Make that non-flow. Personal fouls totaled 54, with three of those called intentional, all against the Aces. There were three technicals, including two against Merfeld. I don't blame him for either.

The first game when Eric Coleman, a long-armed beast of a rebounder for the Panthers, came flying through the lane and treated the rim as if it were a trapeze. He pulled it down, hung there, and swung back and forth.

Somehow all three Saturday night foo-flingers missed something that could easily be used as an example of a rim-hanging technical foul in an officiating class. It was an unexcusable miss by all three.

Merfeld's second came when the Aces were attempting, one of many times, to get back into the game. They were down 49-44 and had the ball on a two-on-one fast break with just under nine minutes to play. Kyle Anslinger was dribbling in the open with the ball; Strickland was running into the lane.

As Anslinger swung wide, Strickland simply stopped, and stood still and upright. There was no butt into the defender, no elbow up or out, nothing. I saw it on tape, in slow-motion even, so I know this is fact.

If there was contact, and I'm not sure there was, it might not even elicit an 'excuse-me' at the mall. And, if there was contact, it was initiated by the defender.

When the whistle came, as it surely would on EVERY play, Strickland was called for an offensive foul. My first reaction, the one I shouted out loud and I rarely ever react openly to ANYTHING at a game, was that it was the worst call I'd ever seen.

Whether it was or not, Merfeld seemed to agree and literally came unglued. At least he got his money's worth on his way to his ejection.

Even the normally-restrained crowd at Roberts Stadium lustily booed the Three Stooges throughout. At least, for once, it made their police escort after the game necessity instead of window dressing.

Did it cost the Aces the game? Probably not. Their six-minute scoring drought to open the game and resulting 11-0 deficit definitely hurt more than the effort that could've passed for a spoof on officiating.

But it could've, just the same. They helped put Jason Holsinger on the bench for a season-low 19 minutes right after he hit two straight 3-pointers. They robbed the game of any flow and 5,592 fans of any enjoyment.

If it was up to me they'd never work in the Missouri Valley Conference again, not even on Saturday night.

bcrawf
02-06-2007, 09:13 AM
The guy does make a good point about Saturday nights. The league does need to do something to address that...

DUBulldog
02-06-2007, 09:17 AM
Let's get their names straight. The lead official, the guy with the shaved head, was Mark Mayhood. The other two, whom I can't differentiate, were Dan Nowakowski and John Moore. We'll consider them an entry.

hmmmm....Dan Nowakowski was the official who had Tom Davis in a tizzy at the end of the Drake-Creighton game Saturday night. Somehow, I don't think he officiated two games that evening.

Just checked the boxscore on yahoo.com......Nowakowski was not listed on the crew at E-ville....some guy named John Grimshaw was the third official in the game.

If the reporter is going to slam the officiating crew, he should at least get their names right.

BradleyBrave
02-06-2007, 09:24 AM
The guy does make a good point about Saturday nights. The league does need to do something to address that...

I thought they did last year. Didn't the MVC up their pay scale for the officials in order to avoid situations like these?

DawgieStyle
02-06-2007, 09:25 AM
OH, look, another the refs suck thread on VT...what a surprise. :chair:

Bigcityp
02-06-2007, 09:26 AM
It doesn't surprise me at all that the local guys can't get it right! I looked up the box score on ESPN.com and they have the officials listed as

Officials: Mark Mayhood, Richard Grimshaw, Terry Oglesby

I don't have my program still but that may of been where he got the names of the officials and UE could of printed it wrong in there or there was a change and they didn't reprint the programs.

Bigcityp
02-06-2007, 09:59 AM
OH, look, another the refs suck thread on VT...what a surprise. :chair:

This isn't a post on how the Ref's suck. Just wanted to get some talk going after reading this in the local paper. I thought all SIU fans thought the refs suck anyways...

DawgieStyle
02-06-2007, 10:01 AM
This isn't a post on how the Ref's suck. Just wanted to get some talk going after reading this in the local paper. I thought all SIU fans thought the refs suck anyways...

there are good refs, and there are bad refs, but they are good and bad for both teams. My points as always is that refs don't decide games, so I could care less if they are good or bad.

ShockerEngr
02-06-2007, 10:43 AM
there are good refs, and there are bad refs, but they are good and bad for both teams. My points as always is that refs don't decide games, so I could care less if they are good or bad.

I care because i hate watching the ref's show instead of the game. It's not about an unfair advantage for either team, but more of a fans enjoyment of a game.

When a ref takes over a game, it's not much fun to watch, and i'm sure it's not much fun to play....for either team.

SycEm
02-06-2007, 10:53 AM
I thought they did last year. Didn't the MVC up their pay scale for the officials in order to avoid situations like these?
You can find the payscale in the MVC Basketball Procedure manual (http://www.mvc.org/manual/mbb.pdf?DB_OEM_ID=7600)
From page 17:
5.1.3 Fees.
a. Game fee. A tiered system shall determine the officiating game
fee:
E-Tier $1800 flat fee - Wednesday & Saturday
$1600 - non-Wednesday/Saturday
Level I $1200 flat fee
Level II $1000 flat fee
Level III $ 850 flat fee
See Appendix 1 for criteria for each level.
b. Per diem. Discontinued; included in flat fee.
c. Travel. Discontinued; included in flat fee.
d. Exhibition Game. $300 flat fee.

To understand the "Tier" System, this can be found in Appendix 1 (page 24):
MVC Men’s Basketball Officiating
Flat Fee Policies
E-LEVEL - $1800 Wednesday & Saturday assignments; $1600 non-Wednesday/Saturday
assignment
As determined annually by the MVC Officiating Committee.
LEVEL I - $1200
(must meet four out of six constraints)
1. Minimum of five years of service to the MVC.
2. Minimum MVC conference-game schedule of ten games for upcoming season.
3. Selected to MVC Tournament the previous year.
4. Selected to the NCAA Division I Tournament the previous year.
5. Used as lead official in a minimum of eight games in MVC assignments for the
upcoming season.
6. Selected to the NCAA Division I Final Four
LEVEL II - $1000
(must meet three out of five constraints)
1. Minimum of five years of service to the MVC.
2. Minimum MVC conference-game schedule of five games for the upcoming
season.
3. Selected to MVC Tournament the previous year.
4. Selected to the NCAA Division I Tournament the previous year.
5. Used as a lead official in a minimum of five games in MVC assignments for the
upcoming season.
LEVEL III - $850
1. Those officials that do not meet the requirements of Level I or Level II.

Bigcityp
02-06-2007, 12:56 PM
You can find the payscale in the MVC Basketball Procedure manual (http://www.mvc.org/manual/mbb.pdf?DB_OEM_ID=7600)
From page 17:
5.1.3 Fees.
a. Game fee. A tiered system shall determine the officiating game
fee:
E-Tier $1800 flat fee - Wednesday & Saturday
$1600 - non-Wednesday/Saturday
Level I $1200 flat fee
Level II $1000 flat fee
Level III $ 850 flat fee
See Appendix 1 for criteria for each level.
b. Per diem. Discontinued; included in flat fee.
c. Travel. Discontinued; included in flat fee.
d. Exhibition Game. $300 flat fee.

To understand the "Tier" System, this can be found in Appendix 1 (page 24):
MVC Men’s Basketball Officiating
Flat Fee Policies
E-LEVEL - $1800 Wednesday & Saturday assignments; $1600 non-Wednesday/Saturday
assignment
As determined annually by the MVC Officiating Committee.
LEVEL I - $1200
(must meet four out of six constraints)
1. Minimum of five years of service to the MVC.
2. Minimum MVC conference-game schedule of ten games for upcoming season.
3. Selected to MVC Tournament the previous year.
4. Selected to the NCAA Division I Tournament the previous year.
5. Used as lead official in a minimum of eight games in MVC assignments for the
upcoming season.
6. Selected to the NCAA Division I Final Four
LEVEL II - $1000
(must meet three out of five constraints)
1. Minimum of five years of service to the MVC.
2. Minimum MVC conference-game schedule of five games for the upcoming
season.
3. Selected to MVC Tournament the previous year.
4. Selected to the NCAA Division I Tournament the previous year.
5. Used as a lead official in a minimum of five games in MVC assignments for the
upcoming season.
LEVEL III - $850
1. Those officials that do not meet the requirements of Level I or Level II.

THose guys were paid that much the other night for what they did?? I figure it's UE fault anyway.. Getting three Level III officials so they can cut costs sounds about write for UE... I just hope that they cut their cost with Merfeld after this year...

-Z-
02-06-2007, 11:54 PM
THose guys were paid that much the other night for what they did?? I figure it's UE fault anyway.. Getting three Level III officials so they can cut costs sounds about write for UE... I just hope that they cut their cost with Merfeld after this year...


I believe that the refs are assigned by the league office, not the schools.

UofL17
02-07-2007, 01:40 AM
If the refs have to be bad to get rid of Merfeld thats fine with me. Watching Evansville basketball used to be so fun under Jim Crews. (I know he had some .500 years as well) Remember 1998? After Merfeld got here and the sleves were taken off the jerseys its been down in the cellar in the MVC. The MVC is a very respectable league but I want the Aces to compete again.

Ace Happy
02-07-2007, 11:36 AM
By Steve Ford (Courier Press writer - his blog)

Meet the sad sacks of Saturday night
Posted February 5, 2007


Welcome to another bizarre Saturday night in the Missouri Valley Conference.

It doesn't really matter who's playing, though, because one thing's for certain on a Saturday night in the Valley: the game will be ugly because the officials are going to stink.

Saturday's home game for the University of Evansville, what would eventually become a 79-71 loss to Northern Iowa, was just another prime example of what has become a running joke in the MVC.

It's all about Saturday night officiating crews. Since all the good referees worked earlier in the day in marquee games, the guys who work Saturday nights are leftovers.

We're talking bad leftovers here, something like serving the surviving snacks from your New Years party for the Super Bowl. They tend to be stale, crumbly and not so good.

Actually, that's being kind. Saturday's crew at Roberts Stadium was awful, not worthy of a junior varsity game at the high school level. In fact, that's exactly what they reminded me of, only these guys should know better.

Let's get their names straight. The lead official, the guy with the shaved head, was Mark Mayhood. The other two, whom I can't differentiate, were Terry Oglesby and Gene Grimshaw. We'll consider them an entry.

It didn't really matter, because it was Mayhood who set the tone from the opening tap, which he attempted to throw. It never got higher than Bradley Strickland's elbow and should've been redone. But noooooooo!

And then things went downhill from there. Mayhood started out by dominating the calls. My estimate late in the first half was that he blew 70 percent of the whistles. Other estimates in the press box were higher.

Then, what usually happens in this situation, did. The entry decided it need to start getting involved at a similar level. The result was chaos.

UE coach Steve Merfeld, who's not supposed to comment, did on his coach's show Sunday night. He said, in so many words, it was the worst game he'd seen in his 21 years of coaching.

If it wasn't at the top of my list, it was close. It was terribly inconsistent from all involved. There was a one-step travel called on one trip and running in place with the ball ignored on the next.

Officials within an arm's length of an assault ignored it one trip then called a hard breath on someone's back a foul from across the floor on the next.

All told the numbers were numbing, same as the flow of the game. Make that non-flow. Personal fouls totaled 54, with three of those called intentional, all against the Aces. There were three technicals, including two against Merfeld. I don't blame him for either.

The first game when Eric Coleman, a long-armed beast of a rebounder for the Panthers, came flying through the lane and treated the rim as if it were a trapeze. He pulled it down, hung there, and swung back and forth.

Somehow all three Saturday night foo-flingers missed something that could easily be used as an example of a rim-hanging technical foul in an officiating class. It was an unexcusable miss by all three.

Merfeld's second came when the Aces were attempting, one of many times, to get back into the game. They were down 49-44 and had the ball on a two-on-one fast break with just under nine minutes to play. Kyle Anslinger was dribbling in the open with the ball; Strickland was running into the lane.

As Anslinger swung wide, Strickland simply stopped, and stood still and upright. There was no butt into the defender, no elbow up or out, nothing. I saw it on tape, in slow-motion even, so I know this is fact.

If there was contact, and I'm not sure there was, it might not even elicit an 'excuse-me' at the mall. And, if there was contact, it was initiated by the defender.

When the whistle came, as it surely would on EVERY play, Strickland was called for an offensive foul. My first reaction, the one I shouted out loud and I rarely ever react openly to ANYTHING at a game, was that it was the worst call I'd ever seen.

Whether it was or not, Merfeld seemed to agree and literally came unglued. At least he got his money's worth on his way to his ejection.

Even the normally-restrained crowd at Roberts Stadium lustily booed the Three Stooges throughout. At least, for once, it made their police escort after the game necessity instead of window dressing.

Did it cost the Aces the game? Probably not. Their six-minute scoring drought to open the game and resulting 11-0 deficit definitely hurt more than the effort that could've passed for a spoof on officiating.

But it could've, just the same. They helped put Jason Holsinger on the bench for a season-low 19 minutes right after he hit two straight 3-pointers. They robbed the game of any flow and 5,592 fans of any enjoyment.

If it was up to me they'd never work in the Missouri Valley Conference again, not even on Saturday night.

Ace Happy
02-07-2007, 11:58 AM
I apologize for the reposting of this article. I didn't realize it was posted before so if the moderator would like to delete my moved & unnecessary post, please do so!